Yes, absolutely. Associate editors evaluate every review. The rating scale used in these evaluations is reprinted in Gary Ballinger and Russell Johnson’s (2015) essay on how to be an AMR reviewer (see page 320). Their essay can be accessed through our website at Reviewer Resources or through your library.
Source: Ballinger, G.A. & Johnson, R.E. 2015. Editors’ comments: Your first AMR review. Academy of Management Review, 40: 315–322.